Friday, November 01, 2019

A Catholic conudrum

The Magisterium must seek to present a convincing case, showing how its presentation of the faith is in itself coherent and in continuity with the rest of Tradition. The authority of the papal Magisterium rests on its continuity with the teachings of previous popes. In fact, if a pope had the power to abolish the binding teachings of his predecessors, or if he had the authority even to reinterpret Holy Scripture against its evident meaning, then all his doctrinal decisions could in turn be abolished by his successor, whose successor in turn could undo or redo everything as he pleased. In this case we would not be witnessing a development of doctrine, but the dire spectacle of the Bark of Peter stranded on a sandbank.


Gerhard Ludwig Cardinal Müller is former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

1 comment:

  1. So basically, we can do whatever we want because we are "the Church."

    And people wonder why so many people reject Roman Catholicism.

    ReplyDelete