Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Blomberg on baptism

As we noted earlier, there is another kind of disagreement that creates complex interpretive problems. This one is subtle because it may not emerge just from a cursory study of the text or recent scholarly literature.
On the one hand, survey of the most recent scholarship on John 3:3-5 will show a fair consensus rejecting the view that the rebirth for which Jesus calls in 3:3,5 refers (at least in the context of the historical Jesus) to the Christian rite of baptism. On the other hand, most of the church fathers and other commentators throughout history have strongly believed that if not Jesus then certainly John the Evangelist did intend to refer to water baptism in these two verses. Put differently, the patristic authors often appeared to attribute to biblical characters interpretations that could only have developed at a later time without differentiating the two time periods.
If leading orthodox interpreters in eras past have come to conclusions other than ours today, it is not due to intellectual inferiority or lack of discipline. It often has more to do with the lack of developed literary tools and accessibility to wide-ranging information to the degree that we now enjoy.
In the case of John 3:3,5 on being “born again” (or “from above”), the advent and increasing practice of both historical-cultural and literary criticism were the paramount catalysts that encouraged contemporary interpreters to opt against understanding gennethe anothen as a reference to baptism. When an interpreter reads the text in its original context as an accurate summary of a historical conversation that took place between Jesus and Nicodemus, baptism becomes less of a possibility.
The immediate context of Jesus’s conversation with Nicodemus makes it difficult to sustain a baptismal interpretation of the text. While it is true that by the time John wrote his Gospel narrative, most likely in the 90s, the rite of Christian baptism was well recognized, that was not yet the case during Jesus’s life. In the Gospels, Jesus’s disciples are not commissioned to baptize, in the full Christian sense, until the Great Commission after his death and resurrection (Mt 28:19-20). Additionally, there is no conclusive evidence that the baptism of John the Baptist was so well known that simple referral to water would have conjured up images of John’s baptism of repentance for any of the characters in the narrative. In 4:1-3 we learn of a ministry of baptism under Jesus, but we have not arrived at that point in the narrative yet in 3:3-5. If a discourse on the necessity of baptism is the evangelist’s final goal, then “this part of the account, at least, becomes a narrative fiction designed to instruct the church [i.e. at a later date] on the importance of baptism.” This ultimately would render John a confused storyteller, inasmuch as a few verses later in the conversation (3:10) Jesus is reprimanding Nicodemus for not understanding something that he would not have been able to understand anyway. However, “born of water and the Spirit” could very easily have led Nicodemus, who was well versed in the Hebrew Scriptures, to recall Ezekiel 36:25-27.

C. Blomberg, A Handbook of New Testament Exegesis (Baker 2010), 188-90. 

GTY on hell

The GTY blog has a running series on hell, in response to issues raised by the Bell controversy:

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110412

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110414

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110421

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110426

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110430

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110506

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B110511

POWs on "torture"

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/post/mccains-fellow-pows-support-waterboarding/2011/05/16/AF0f374G_blog.html

Augustus Caesar, pontifex maximus, becomes a god

The dragon stood on the shore of the sea. And I saw a beast coming out of the sea. It had ten horns and seven heads, with ten crowns on its horns, and on each head a blasphemous name. The beast I saw resembled a leopard, but had feet like those of a bear and a mouth like that of a lion. The dragon gave the beast his power and his throne and great authority. One of the heads of the beast seemed to have had a fatal wound, but the fatal wound had been healed. The whole world was filled with wonder and followed the beast. People worshiped the dragon because he had given authority to the beast, and they also worshiped the beast and asked, “Who is like the beast? Who can wage war against it?”

As a young man, having grown up devoutly Roman Catholic and now struggling to leave that “church”, I had an understanding that the papacy was a key to my struggles. An “office” that extended 2000 years back through history to Christ was certainly an impressive show of authority. I grew up with the understanding that Matthew 16:18 said “Thou art Peter, and on this rock I will build my Catholic Church.” But I read the New Testament and I came away from it with no sense at all of Roman Catholicism.

How could “Roman Catholicism” and “New Testament Christianity” have diverged so sharply?

Monday, May 16, 2011

By their fruitcakes shall you know them

I’m going to piggyback on a point made by Patrick Chan. If it’s logical to judge Christianity by Harold Camping, then it’s logical to judge atheism by Kevin Bacon, Jeffrey Dahmer, Larry Flynt, Barry Manilow, Marilyn Manson, Keanu Reeves, Howard Stern, &c. 

"Forever and ever"

One argument annihilationists sometimes use is that the “eonian” terminology of Scripture doesn’t mean “eternal” because it has reference to a two-age scheme: this age and the age to come. As such, that says nothing about the duration of the coming age. It just indicates one age followed by another age. An epochal distinction.

But there are two or three basic problems with this argument:

i) Standard NT lexicons give “eternal” as a definition of aionios. Cf. BDAG 35b (#’s 2-3).

ii) Even on a two-age scheme, the age to come is supposed to stand in contrast to this age, which is characterized by mortality. If the present age represents death, the age to come represents a deathless existence.

Of course, the annihilationist may claim that a deathless existence only pertains to the saints, and not to the damned. That, however, is not an implication of the two-age scheme. At best, that’s an overlay.

iii) In Revelation, we have an iterative formula: “forever and ever,” “unto the ages of the ages” (eis tous aionos ton aionon, e.g. 19:3; 20:10).

That’s not a two-age scheme. It's not a contrast between the present age and the age to come. Rather, the whole phrase denotes the age to come. An expansive, open-ended formulation which indicates everlasting duration. 

Is Camping an embarrassment?

Should we be embarrassed by Camping? No. Protestants have always said you should never blindly follow uninspired men. That’s why we’re not Roman Catholics or Eastern Orthodox. Camping illustrates the very thing that Protestantism has been warning against for centuries. He proves our point.

So he’s no embarrassment to Protestants. Rather, he’s just a mini-Pope.

The Protestant movement was also concerned with restoring responsible hermeneutics. Protestant theological method eschews rampant allegory and the fourfold sense of Scripture (i.e. the Quadriga).  We eschew esoteric interpretations. Camping argues from Scripture the way Catholic epologists spooftext Marian dogma from the ark of the covenant.

The morning after

What should we say to unbelievers who use the Camping debacle to justify their infidelity?

i) We can point to the paradoxical fact that false prophecy is a confirmation of true prophecy. Jesus predicted false Christian prophets. Predicted charlatan doomsday prognosticators:

“4And Jesus answered them, "See that no one leads you astray. 5For many will come in my name, saying, 'I am the Christ,' and they will lead many astray…23 Then if anyone says to you, 'Look, here is the Christ!' or 'There he is!' do not believe it. 24For false christs and false prophets will arise and perform great signs and wonders, so as to lead astray, if possible, even the elect. 25See, I have told you beforehand. 26So, if they say to you, 'Look, he is in the wilderness,' do not go out. If they say, 'Look, he is in the inner rooms,' do not believe it. 27” (Mt 24:4-5,23-27).

This is nothing new or unexpected.

ii) If an unbeliever uses a buffoon like Camping as a pretext to justify his infidelity, then the unbeliever is playing right into God’s hands. For God uses scandals in the church to drive some reprobates away from the faith. To harden them in their apostasy or infidelity.

It isn’t just Camping’s followers who are dupes. Unbelievers who use his example to excuse their infidelity are also dupes. For Camping is an instrument to expose their irrational disbelief. A reasonable man would never judge the Christian faith by a wingnut like Camping. Camping is a loon, but if you use his lunacy to justify your infidelity, then you, too, are a loon. If that’s the reason you reject the Christian faith, then God played you for a chump. So that’s nothing to be proud of. Don’t pat yourself on the back.

Camping is a fool who played his followers for fools, but only a fool would reject the Christian faith on Camping’s account (or related reasons). A deluded unbeliever mocking a deluded believer occupies the same leaky lifeboat. 

Hypothetical arguments for Catholicism

I. The Hypothetical Argument for Catholicism

A popular argument for Roman Catholicism takes this basic form: If God gave us an infallible text, then he’d give us an infallible interpreter.

Variations on this type of argument are adapted to analogous claims, viz., If God gave us a collection of infallible books, he’d give us an infallible collector; if God gave us his Word, he’d give us an infallible Church to assure us that the Bible is his Word.

II. The Hypothetical Counterargument

What these arguments have in common is their hypothetical character. But this type of argument suffers from a basic liability: For every hypothetical argument, it’s often child’s play to propose a hypothetical alternative.

Consider the following:

If God gave us an infallible text, but didn’t give us an infallible interpreter, then an infallible interpreter is unnecessary for God to teach us what he intends to have us to believe.

If God gave us a collection of infallible books, but didn’t give us an infallible collector, then an infallible collector is unnecessary to discover the correct canon of Scripture.

If God gave us his Word, but didn’t give us an infallible Church, then an infallible Church is unnecessary to assure us that the Bible is his Word.

Put another way, the hypothetical arguments for Catholicism are reversible. You can take a hypothetical argument for Catholicism, and by a Moore shift, turn that into a hypothetical counterargument against Catholicism.

III. Plausible Alternatives

Incidentally, it isn’t difficult to flesh out the hypothetical alternatives. For instance, if the Protestant canon of Scripture is the correct canon, and God wants someone to believe in the Protestant canon, then he can do so causing that person to attend a Protestant church.

God could cultivate that belief through opportune social conditioning. In this case, special providence is a reliable belief-forming mechanism. In this case, God has prearranged historical events so that Protestant churches adhere to the true canon. And God has prearranged historical events so that some individuals will be born at such a time and place that they will attend a Protestant church, where they will be conditioned to believe in the true canon of Scripture.

This doesn’t mean that providence, per se, yields true beliefs. Rather, this has reference to situations in which God intentionally employs providential circumstances to foster a true belief in the canon of Scripture.

So it could be a simple as that. What is more, this happens to be a very realistic model of how most OT Jews and NT Christians actually form their beliefs. Their beliefs are largely the result of their natural aptitudes, historical opportunities, and formative experiences.

At the same time, it’s also possible for more sophisticated Christians to confirm their belief in the Protestant canon through various lines of evidence.

But even if you’re in no position to prove it, the fact that you’re in no position to prove it could be a special providential circumstance. God brought you to a true belief in the canon, not by historical evidence, but by historical events. By exposing you to external conditions which are divinely designed to induce true beliefs. 

Universalism, Colossians 1:15-20, and the Already/Not Yet

A favored proof-text for universalism is Colossians 1:15-20,

15 The Son is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn over all creation. 16 For in him all things were created: things in heaven and on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or powers or rulers or authorities; all things have been created through him and for him. 17 He is before all things, and in him all things hold together. 18 And he is the head of the body, the church; he is the beginning and the firstborn from among the dead, so that in everything he might have the supremacy. 19For God was pleased to have all his fullness dwell in him, 20 and through him to reconcile to himself all things, whether things on earth or things in heaven, by making peace through his blood, shed on the cross.

There is a lot to comment on this passage as regards to its employment as a universalist proof text. However, in this post I’ll just raise one worry for the universalist reading since I haven’t seen this issue raised or addressed in universalist literature. I will first briefly provide the universalist understanding of the text and then point out one strange implication of it.

Cutting to the chase, the issue comes to the forefront at verse 20. It is argued that the “all things” reconciled has the same scope as the “all things” in verse 16, which is, literally, everything (other than God). The verb for restoration, apokatallaso, presupposes a rupture in a relationship which needs to be repaired or restored. In the only other place Paul uses this word (Eph. 2:14-16), the restoration is unto a harmonious relationship. The peace made is through the blood of the cross, which seems to suggest salvation is in view. Salvation and harmony can be seen in other Pauline letters where he uses the root of apokatallaso, such as Romans 5; 1, 10. And later in Romans 5:22-22, we read that “reconciliation” is unto salvation. So, it is argued, Paul is speaking of the salvation of all or the restoration of all unto a harmonious relationship with its Creator. No reconciled beings can remain hostile to God, as the word and the exegesis show. So, as universalist Robin Parry writes, “The word and the context make it abundantly clear that Paul speaks of salvation when he speaks of reconciliation and that, as long as a being remains hostile to God, it cannot be said to be reconciled to him” (Evangelical Universalist, 46).

An initial problem arises when Parry writes, “Paul does not think that this redemption is something God hopes will come to pass in the future. He maintains that it is something already accomplished in Christ. In Christ the whole creation is already reconciled.” But a few sentences earlier, Parry writes, “One could hardly imagine Paul supposing that one of Christ’s enemies suffering eschatological punishment was in a state of peace with God!” (ibid, emphasis mine).

So Parry has said that a being who is hostile toward God cannot be said to be reconciled to him, but he also said that the whole creation is “already” reconciled. However, it is clear that many of God’s creatures are in a state of hostility toward him now, and so how could it be that all are already reconciled if none reconciled can be in a state of hostility toward God? Thus we have a contradiction.

Surely that was too fast. Parry, as a good evangelical universalist, will appeal to the eschatological hermeneutical principle of the already/not yet (cf. p.50-53). So we can grant him that there’s no contradiction between there being hostile beings now even though it is true that all have been reconciled now, for this is consistent with “not” all being reconciled “yet” (consistent according to the already/not yet hermeneutic). The historic or classical Christian makes the same moves. Christ has defeated all of his enemies now, yet we still see enemies seemingly undefeated. They are “not yet” defeated. So far, Parry's claim shouldn’t be a problem for the traditional Christian.

But another problem arises. While it seems clear that the Bible teaches a two age construct where the already/not yet applies in the present evil age or the last days, the Bible nowhere teaches a continued “not yet” in the age to come. When Christ comes again and fully realizes the age to come, so that the age to come is the present reality, the sheep and goats are separated (which does not happen now), we will actually be fully sanctified (which does not happen now), the enemies of Christ will actually and fully be defeated (which doesn’t happen now), we will be completely and totally resurrected (which does not happen now), etc. Paul speaks of “present sufferings of this age” (Romans 8:20) which will be absent in “the age to come.” Knowing this is one reason why we can bear the sufferings now, for we know they will be gone in the new age. In the age to come, “the old is completely passed away” and all will be new. The things of this present age are temporary, they will pass away, they are not part of the new age. However, we have deposits, down payments on the life to come. The age to come has broken into this present evil age, inaugurating the age to come. Now, recall that Parry states, "One could hardly imagine Paul supposing that one of Christ’s enemies suffering eschatological punishment was in a state of peace with God!” Leaving aside the point that subjugated and non-compliant enemies can be said to be at peace with the conqueror, one could hardly imagine Paul supposing that the temporary elements of this present age are a continued, ongoing reality in the age to come!

How is all of this relevant to Parry’s exegesis of Colossians 1:15-20? Recall that Parry wrote that an enemy of Christ’s suffering in hell could not be said to be at peace with God. Recall that he said that no one who is hostile toward God can be said to be reconciled. But Parry also places unrepentant sinners in hell in the age to come. These sinners will be in hell until they repent and trust in Christ for their salvation. Thus, there will be people hostile to God in the age to come. There will be actually unreconciled creatures in the age to come. Parry got around this problem here and now by making use of the two age construct and the already not yet. But on Parry’s view, that construct must also carry over in the age to come. There must be an already/not yet in the age of what is now the not yet! But this idea, I suggest, is totally foreign to the teaching of Scripture. The already/not yet is a hermeneutical principle used to make sense of the two ages, of the in-breaking of the age to come into this present age. But it seems Parry needs that construct to apply even in the age to come, where it supposedly has no purchase. I suggest Paul would be amazed to learn that the already/not yet still applied to the universe after Jesus returns. This seems highly counter-intuitive to say the least, and it is in need of exegetical support of which there currently is none.

Missing the Mother Ship

http://the-porters-lodge.blogspot.com/2011/05/answer.html

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Aging hippies in vestments

“Tom” Wright has written an open letter which is making the rounds of the Internet. Oddly enough, it seems to have vanished from the originating site.

Before I discuss his analogous illustrations, let’s begin with what actually went down. From what I’ve heard and read, as well as considering what’s innately plausible, US forces staged a unilateral strike on UBL’s safe house. We didn’t notify the Pakistani authorities in advance because elements within the Pakistani gov’t collaborate with the jihadis, and if we tipped them off, they’d turn around and tip off UBL. Indeed, given the fact that Pakistan is a police state, as well as the location of UBL’s conspicuous safe house in a populous military town, it seems highly probable that elements within the Pakistani gov’t were consciously harboring UBL.

Now, I have no independent knowledge of what transpired. And I don’t believe everything I’m told. However, what I’ve summarized is consistent with a thoroughly cynical interpretation of both the Pakistani gov’t and the Obama administration. Therefore, I don’t say this because I trust the “official” story.

I also think there were too many different players in the operation, and the operation itself was too high-profile, for conspiracy theories to hold water.

Universalism, Annihilationism, And The Early Church

I've addressed the early church's view of Hell in previous posts on this blog, but I think some recent developments warrant a return to the subject. I recently read a post by Paul Helm about universalism in the early church. He makes some good points, but doesn't go into much depth. Last month, Victor Reppert linked to an article claiming that universalism was the majority view in the earliest centuries of church history. That article makes a lot of misleading claims, some of which I'll address below. Before I do that, however, I want to summarize my own position on this issue.

Obi-Wan Kenobi Is Dead, Vader Says

This just in:
“CORUSCANT — Obi-Wan Kenobi, the mastermind of some of the most devastating attacks on the Galactic Empire and the most hunted man in the galaxy, was killed in a firefight with Imperial forces near Alderaan, Darth Vader announced on Sunday.

In a late-night appearance in the East Room of the Imperial Palace, Lord Vader declared that “justice has been done” as he disclosed that agents of the Imperial Army and stormtroopers of the 501st Legion had finally cornered Kenobi, one of the leaders of the Jedi rebellion, who had eluded the Empire for nearly two decades. Imperial officials said Kenobi resisted and was cut down by Lord Vader's own lightsaber. He was later dumped out of an airlock.”
Read more …

"Cranmer" on Dawkins

http://archbishop-cranmer.blogspot.com/2011/05/richard-dawkins-refuses-to-debate.html

Running scared

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/8511931/Richard-Dawkins-accused-of-cowardice-for-refusing-to-debate-existence-of-God.html

"Analogies and the Death of Bin Laden"

Francis Beckwith responds to N.T. Wright's argument on the allegedly "unjust" killing of Osama bin Laden.

Saturday, May 14, 2011

Merlin redux



I've been watching the BBC show Merlin (which Steve also blogged about here). I watched the episodes out of sequence though, since I was originally just dipping into them and not expecting to watch too many of them. But I believe I've seen all of them now.

Life on the run

Let's say Jesus really was a mere human and died on the cross. He wasn't raised from the dead.
  1. I would think a group of first century Jewish dissidents who had just had their leader executed would probably only have two viable choices:

    a. They could entirely give up their movement. Indeed, the Gospels relate that was what most if not all of the apostles wanted to do. Among other things, they didn't have the emotional wherewithal to continue the movement.

    b. Or they could find another leader to take their original leader's place. Maybe they'd have picked Peter. Although the Gospels portray Peter as feeling so dejected after lying about being a follower of Jesus and demonstrating his cowardice, and thus betrayal of Jesus, that being any sort of a leader was probably the farthest thing from his mind (and indeed Jesus had to restore Peter as the Gospel of John relates). Or maybe they'd have picked James who was Jesus' brother and who of course later did become a leader in the early church. But at this point Jesus' family including James didn't believe in him or his movement, as the Gospels tell.

    I would think the last thing anyone would expect would be for the same group of dissidents to start telling everyone that their leader who had just been executed was still alive if they truly believed and knew he was dead. How unrealistic! I mean, who's gonna believe that kind of a message? It's not as if first century Jews didn't know what happened when people were crucified and killed. They knew people who were killed stayed dead. So telling everyone that their deceased leader whom they knew was dead was alive again would seem to strain credulity, to put it mildly.

    Jason Engwer notes N.T. Wright argues much the same:
    So far as we know, all the followers of these first-century messianic movements were fanatically committed to the cause. They, if anybody, might be expected to suffer from this blessed twentieth century disease called "cognitive dissonance" when their expectations failed to materialize. But in no case, right across the century before Jesus and the century after him, do we hear of any Jewish group saying that their executed leader had been raised from the dead and he really was the Messiah after all. (Cited in Paul Copan and Ronald Tacelli, edd., Jesus' Resurrection: Fact or Figment? [Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 2000], p. 183)
  2. But let's say the apostles did do precisely this. And let's say many of their fellow Jewish people did believe their message. Let's say the apostles and their message was now the talk of the town too. Jerusalem was abuzz with news that Jesus was alive again (even though he really wasn't). People were eager to hear more about this Jesus and his message from his followers. Thus the apostles had a huge and popular platform with the public.

    I would think it'd be more likely than not that these first century Jews would be tempted to use such a platform to undermine Rome's authority over Israel in some way (maybe especially Simon the Zealot). Indeed, the Romans themselves seemed to have thought that's what the apostles were really trying to do with Jesus.

    But instead the apostles used their platform to make their central message about turning away from one's sinful, rebellious life against God (not Rome) and trusting in Jesus as the true Lord God and Savior to justly forgive people for their sinful, rebellious life against God (not Rome). They didn't use their platform to deliver the message that people should disrespect the civil authorities, overthrow the Roman Empire, and so forth. In fact, they even asked people to respect the civil authorities.

    After all, what else could realistically be the apostles' motivation for seeking to continue and expand their movement despite knowing that Jesus really was dead? What else could be their real intention, especially in light of the fact that they were forced against their will to live as otherwise innocent men being hunted down one by one by their fellow Jews and others? This might make for a good movie but hardly a good life!

  3. Of course, we read what Gamaliel said in Acts 5:34-39:
    But a Pharisee in the council named Gamaliel, a teacher of the law held in honor by all the people, stood up and gave orders to put the men outside for a little while. And he said to them, "Men of Israel, take care what you are about to do with these men. For before these days Theudas rose up, claiming to be somebody, and a number of men, about four hundred, joined him. He was killed, and all who followed him were dispersed and came to nothing. After him Judas the Galilean rose up in the days of the census and drew away some of the people after him. He too perished, and all who followed him were scattered. So in the present case I tell you, keep away from these men and let them alone, for if this plan or this undertaking is of man, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will not be able to overthrow them. You might even be found opposing God!"

An overview of the Jesus quest

These are just some notes on Craig Blomberg's lecture on the historical Jesus. Blomberg in turn acknowledged he took a fair portion of his material from Ben Witherington. I used Google, Wikipedia, and the like to fill in the gaps I noticed.

I've interspersed my own comments here. Sorry they're not clearly labeled or anything. I took these notes down rather quickly and a bit haphazardly too. I didn't intend to post these notes, but just started taking notes for myself so I could better follow Blomberg's lecture. These notes are pretty rough to put it mildly.

Anyway, please feel free to make corrections if you spot mistakes, poor points, etc.