Totalitarianism can take difference forms. In some cases, when the supreme leader is too aged and enfeebled to defend himself, an ambitious general stages a coup d’etat by assassinating the supreme leader and brazenly assuming the reins of government. Some ambitious generals bask in the limelight. They revel in the cult of personality.
But other ambitious generals are subtler. They find it useful to have a beloved, but senile, figurehead who’s the public face of the autocratic regime. On the one hand, he’s too ineffectual to interfere with whoever is actually running the show. On the other hand, he gives cover to whoever is actually running the show. As a beloved, adulated figurehead, it’s easier to implement unpopular policies under the aegis of the venerable and avuncular supreme leader.
This resembles the relationship between the Bible and the Magisterium in Roman Catholicism. In Catholicism, the Bible is the titular head of state. Ritual obeisance is paid to the nominal supremacy of Scripture. But behind the genuflections to Scripture, the Magisterium calls the shots.
And, of course, this is a prescription for tyranny. Just as a military dictator is a law unto himself, when there’s no check on the Magisterium, it succumbs to delusions of grandeur. Unbridled corruption. It makes the sort of mistakes that only an institution which deems itself immune from error can make.
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Wednesday, July 01, 2009
Arminianism's Loving God: Giving His kids what they want
Recently "Bossmanham" stopped by and graced the comments with his usual unsubstantive rants against Calvinism. So I did something I have never done. I clicked on his name and saw he had a blog. Over at his place I saw a post where he was struggling to reconcile his belief in a God that loves all men in exactly the same way (and whose love is so primary that all other attributes get demoted in the process of magnifying the one that, ironically, is the most appealing to atheists and other God-haters), but yet sends some men to hell. Bossmanham gave the typical Arminian, LFW, answer: "Well, the loving thing is to let his children have what they want."
Really? Is that really the most loving thing to do in all circumstances? I don't think so. Look at the picture above. Perhaps that's a picture of a child who wanted nothing but candy to eat, so his dad gave it to him and didn't take him to the dentist, because his son didn't want to go there. After all, that's the loving thing to do.
No, given Arminians terms, the most loving thing to do is force, if you must, all men to accept Christ, just like a loving father would force his child to not eat so many sweets and go to the dentist, whether the kid wanted to or not.
I fail to find what Arminians like Bossmanham find so persuasive with what looks to be an obviously false position.
Arminians, beware, Universalism looms large on the horizon.
Arminian 4 eva
Dan is a dyed-in-the-wool Arminian and seemingly can't ever admit that any case for Arminianism, or LFW, no matter how bad, is faulty. Can't even so much as concede even the slightest point. Not much I can do about that. You definitely can't have much of a dialogue with people of this stripe. Not only that, if I wanted this kind of behavior, I could watch Sean Hannity, and at least receive some entertainment for my troubles. :-)
Anyway, in response to my post, which a majority of libertarians who specialize in the metaphysics of free will agree with me over against Dan BTW, Dan simply digs a deeper hole, leaving me not much work to do by way of response.
We can first note that all three of the points in my post defeated Dan's argument, he only dealt with one point, leaving his argument still with undefeated defeaters.
Secondly, his argument has been subtly changed, and I'm unsure whether even he is aware of what he is now implicitly arguing. Dan tried to use Kane to show that Kane agreed with Dan over me, when he doesn't, and I've emailed Kane extensively enough to verify this. He now cites Kane arguing what some choices need to be free or morally responsible. But of course I already anticipated this move (cf. my discussion with Timpe). The further points Dan cites from Kane argue that a free or morally responsible choice cannot be made on determinism. This is not a definitional issue anymore but, rather, involves us in a substantive philosophical discussion about the details of the metaphysics of free will and moral responsibility. Kane flatly and obviously grants that we can choose on determinism, he denies that we can do so freely or responsibly. By moving the debate into the highly contentious and detailed and sophisticated realm of the variegated views on free will and moral responsibility, Dan has completely undermined his initial argument! What's worse, we've just shown the massive question begging nature of his argument. He is assuming a contentious and hotly debated metaphysical position. Dan wants to get a free pass on the tough part of the debate. I've shown that when just sticking with "choice," then there is no problem. Now, if one wants to say that a free or morally responsible "choice" is unintelligible, one is free to make that argument, but not assume it. Furthermore, it is wide of the mark of trying to claim one is just making a "common man" argument. Dan's reply, unbeknownst to him, to be sure, only served to further weaken his initial argument.
Dan ignores wide swaths of my post and hopes his Arminian readers will too. I have severely paralyzed his dictionary argument by pointing out that it is silent as to whether the ability to do otherwise is to be read counter factually. Even if we both think this is the wrong analysis, the point is, you don't get its false truth value from the dictionary. Dan totally ignores my rebutting defeater which his entire claim rests on. His view of what any and all common man believes just seems, well, false.He therefore has been shown to make empirically dubious announcements about what 'common man' (whatever that is) believes. I also subjected his view to some serious reductions, and those were not addressed either. All in all, it must be admitted that his response wis underwhelming, and unable to meet the challenges set for him.
There is nothing to Dan's argument, and I'll let readers decide which case is more persuasive. If Dan can't admit the defeated status of his argument from my last post, I'm unsure of what would, or could, possibly convince Dan. It seems that he is so bent on his pet argument that he isn't even bothered by the fact that it could (a) possibly prove determinism (since it's possible all the dictionaries could write very deterministic sounding definitions) and (b) prove the errancy of Scripture because, without begging the question, Dan must admit that common men and dictionaries (grating Dan's interpretation of the empirical data for sake of argument, which I don't in reality) could be wrong, thus making the Bible assert falsehoods. I guess he could say that this could not be the case since LFW is true, but then if we're going to argue that way, why bother will all the posting and posturing?
Anyway, in response to my post, which a majority of libertarians who specialize in the metaphysics of free will agree with me over against Dan BTW, Dan simply digs a deeper hole, leaving me not much work to do by way of response.
We can first note that all three of the points in my post defeated Dan's argument, he only dealt with one point, leaving his argument still with undefeated defeaters.
Secondly, his argument has been subtly changed, and I'm unsure whether even he is aware of what he is now implicitly arguing. Dan tried to use Kane to show that Kane agreed with Dan over me, when he doesn't, and I've emailed Kane extensively enough to verify this. He now cites Kane arguing what some choices need to be free or morally responsible. But of course I already anticipated this move (cf. my discussion with Timpe). The further points Dan cites from Kane argue that a free or morally responsible choice cannot be made on determinism. This is not a definitional issue anymore but, rather, involves us in a substantive philosophical discussion about the details of the metaphysics of free will and moral responsibility. Kane flatly and obviously grants that we can choose on determinism, he denies that we can do so freely or responsibly. By moving the debate into the highly contentious and detailed and sophisticated realm of the variegated views on free will and moral responsibility, Dan has completely undermined his initial argument! What's worse, we've just shown the massive question begging nature of his argument. He is assuming a contentious and hotly debated metaphysical position. Dan wants to get a free pass on the tough part of the debate. I've shown that when just sticking with "choice," then there is no problem. Now, if one wants to say that a free or morally responsible "choice" is unintelligible, one is free to make that argument, but not assume it. Furthermore, it is wide of the mark of trying to claim one is just making a "common man" argument. Dan's reply, unbeknownst to him, to be sure, only served to further weaken his initial argument.
Dan ignores wide swaths of my post and hopes his Arminian readers will too. I have severely paralyzed his dictionary argument by pointing out that it is silent as to whether the ability to do otherwise is to be read counter factually. Even if we both think this is the wrong analysis, the point is, you don't get its false truth value from the dictionary. Dan totally ignores my rebutting defeater which his entire claim rests on. His view of what any and all common man believes just seems, well, false.He therefore has been shown to make empirically dubious announcements about what 'common man' (whatever that is) believes. I also subjected his view to some serious reductions, and those were not addressed either. All in all, it must be admitted that his response wis underwhelming, and unable to meet the challenges set for him.
There is nothing to Dan's argument, and I'll let readers decide which case is more persuasive. If Dan can't admit the defeated status of his argument from my last post, I'm unsure of what would, or could, possibly convince Dan. It seems that he is so bent on his pet argument that he isn't even bothered by the fact that it could (a) possibly prove determinism (since it's possible all the dictionaries could write very deterministic sounding definitions) and (b) prove the errancy of Scripture because, without begging the question, Dan must admit that common men and dictionaries (grating Dan's interpretation of the empirical data for sake of argument, which I don't in reality) could be wrong, thus making the Bible assert falsehoods. I guess he could say that this could not be the case since LFW is true, but then if we're going to argue that way, why bother will all the posting and posturing?
Tuesday, June 30, 2009
Some Comments On The Mark Sanford Story
1. The Media Research Center has had some good material on recent media coverage of the Mark Sanford story. For example:
2. I heard Michael Medved discuss the Sanford story on his radio program last week, as I was driving home from work. I might not be remembering all of the details correctly. For those who don't know, Medved used to be involved in politics. He discussed one campaign he was involved in with, as I recall, thirteen other people. Of those fourteen people, eight got divorced sometime during the campaign. Medved didn't get divorced himself, since he wasn't married at the time, though he was sexually involved with his girlfriend. He estimates that something like half of those involved in politics, regardless of party affiliation, have been involved in adultery at some point. He discussed some of the reasons why politicians would be involved in adultery to an unusual degree, and his reasoning seemed convincing to me. He noted, for example, that politicians travel a lot, are away from their families more than most people are, and are the type of people who are willing to "beg people for money", as I think he put it, in the process of running for office. He suggested that people willing to do what politicians do to get elected and reelected would also be more likely to get involved in behavior like adultery, because of some overlap between such types of behavior. Those who want to influence politicians don't just use money. They use other means of influence as well.
3. Though sexual sin is common and should be taken seriously, I see no reason to consider it the most common sin, and there are dangers to thinking too highly of it, just as there are dangers in thinking too little of it. Many men commit adultery, but, apparently, judging from statistics I've heard over the years, most don't. We should acknowledge our potential to become involved in sexual sin. But we should also be realistic about our potential to avoid it, as Joseph, Daniel, and many other Biblical figures did. We live in a highly sexualized culture, where sexual sin is easily available, in some contexts more easily available than at any other time in history. But many men avoid sexual sins like adultery, and thinking too highly of the significance of such temptations is dangerous, just as it's dangerous to not think highly enough of those temptations. There are other sins that are more common and more destructive than something like lust or adultery, and making sexual temptations out to be more than they actually are is counterproductive. God is more enjoyable and more powerful than all sin.
In a 2008 study of evening and morning network newscasts following the Spitzer scandal, NewsBusters’ Rich Noyes found that within the first week of news coverage Spitzer was only identified as a Democrat 20% of the time. However, within the first 24 hours of Sanford’s confession to having an affair, he was identified as a Republican 100% of the time, during coverage on all the networks.
On Wednesday, the NBC Nightly News, which failed to give Spitzer’s party affiliation for three days following his scandal, immediately focused on Sanford’s national role in the Republican Party as anchor Brian Williams declared: "In a Republican Party hungry for young stars, he was one of them: Mark Sanford, the governor of South Carolina...Tonight his political career is in tatters. His state, his party are in some turmoil. And Mark Sanford is no longer being mentioned as a possible GOP nominee for the White House."
2. I heard Michael Medved discuss the Sanford story on his radio program last week, as I was driving home from work. I might not be remembering all of the details correctly. For those who don't know, Medved used to be involved in politics. He discussed one campaign he was involved in with, as I recall, thirteen other people. Of those fourteen people, eight got divorced sometime during the campaign. Medved didn't get divorced himself, since he wasn't married at the time, though he was sexually involved with his girlfriend. He estimates that something like half of those involved in politics, regardless of party affiliation, have been involved in adultery at some point. He discussed some of the reasons why politicians would be involved in adultery to an unusual degree, and his reasoning seemed convincing to me. He noted, for example, that politicians travel a lot, are away from their families more than most people are, and are the type of people who are willing to "beg people for money", as I think he put it, in the process of running for office. He suggested that people willing to do what politicians do to get elected and reelected would also be more likely to get involved in behavior like adultery, because of some overlap between such types of behavior. Those who want to influence politicians don't just use money. They use other means of influence as well.
3. Though sexual sin is common and should be taken seriously, I see no reason to consider it the most common sin, and there are dangers to thinking too highly of it, just as there are dangers in thinking too little of it. Many men commit adultery, but, apparently, judging from statistics I've heard over the years, most don't. We should acknowledge our potential to become involved in sexual sin. But we should also be realistic about our potential to avoid it, as Joseph, Daniel, and many other Biblical figures did. We live in a highly sexualized culture, where sexual sin is easily available, in some contexts more easily available than at any other time in history. But many men avoid sexual sins like adultery, and thinking too highly of the significance of such temptations is dangerous, just as it's dangerous to not think highly enough of those temptations. There are other sins that are more common and more destructive than something like lust or adultery, and making sexual temptations out to be more than they actually are is counterproductive. God is more enjoyable and more powerful than all sin.
Monday, June 29, 2009
The faith-shaped life
From Rev. Ian Hamilton:
Faith and DisappointmentContinued here.
The life of faith is not immune from the disappointments and heartaches of what Paul calls "the sufferings of this present age" (Roms.8v18). God does not exempt his children from unexpected, sorely wounding providences. In 2 Cor.1v8, Paul tells us that the hardships and pressures he and his friends were experiencing were so severe, that "we despaired even of life"! Even in the model life of faith, we find our Lord Jesus Christ experiencing disappointment, opposition, hardships, and bereavement. Nowhere does God imply that his believing children will be cocooned from the struggles, disappointments and perplexities of living in a fallen world. On the contrary, in addition to this the Lord tells us that "everyone who wants to live a godly life in Christ Jesus will be persecuted" (2Tim.3v12). Without this spiritual realism, our lives will become the prisoners of circumstance, rising and falling depending on the kind of circumstances that touch our lives.
But the Lord has given us infinitely more than the grace of spiritual realism in order that we might cope with the heartaches, disappointments and mysteries that inevitably touch our lives. First of all, he promises us his unfailing presence in all our times of need: "Never will I leave you; never will I forsake you" (Hebs.13v5). More than that, he promises to be the indwelling Helper of his children. In the Upper Room, as he faced the Cross, the Lord Jesus assured his disciples, "I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you." (Jn.14v18). He was speaking of his coming in his Spirit to be their abiding indwelling Sanctifier and Friend. Whatever difficulties and disappointments you face, however sore God's unexpected providences, of this you can be sure, you are never alone! All the resources of the Godhead are for you and in you! Believe this!
More than this, God assures us that not one unexpected providence that touches his children's lives is fortuitous. Our God is the One "who works out everything in conformity with the purpose of his will" (Eph.1v11). Here we come face to face with God's unconditional sovereignty. But this truth is revealed in Scripture not as a puzzle to unravel, but as a comfort to embrace! Who is this God who is unconditionally sovereign over all things? He is the God who "spared not his own Son, but gave him up for us all" (Roms.8v32). He is "the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort" (2Cor.1v3). It is our loving heavenly Father who does whatsoever he pleases. Who God is to us in Christ is our assurance that "Our Father's hand will never cause his child a needless tear". Believe this. By faith draw out the comfort of being a dearly loved and precious child of a sovereign and loving Father.
There is another strand of encouragement that God gives to us in his Word. In 2 Cor.1, where Paul recounts the great pressures that were causing him to despair even of life, he tells us that "this happened that we might not rely on ourselves but on God, who raises the dead." God was pleased to bring his servant into such straitened circumstances in order to strengthen his trust and confirm his obedience. Samuel Rutherford made the same point: "Faith is the better for the free air and the sharp winter storm in its face. Grace withereth without adversity." God always has our eternal as well as our present good in mind in his relations with us. John Newton's celebrated hymn, "These Inward Trials", captures the grace of God's dealings with his hard-pressed children. Having asked the Lord for growth in "faith and love and every grace", the child of God finds his life assaulted on all sides by unexpected and sore providences. In response to the Christian's perplexity at what has happened, the Lord replies: "These inward trials I employ, From self and pride to set thee free, And break thy schemes of earthly joy, That thou mayest seek thy all in me." The Lord always and ever has our best before him. He is "the gardener" who lovingly prunes the branches united to his Son so that they will bear "even more fruit" (see Jn.15v1-2).
Until we go to be with the Lord, we will find unexpected, and sore, providences touching our lives. It cannot be otherwise, for the servant is not greater than the Master! But, though we might well be hard pressed on every side, we are never crushed. Though we might well be perplexed, we are never in despair. Even if we are persecuted, we are never abandoned. (see 2Cor.4v8-9). God will not exempt us from the tears or the pains; but he will be with you, and in you, every step of the way, bringing the infinite resources of the Godhead graciously to sustain you and make you "more than a conqueror". He who promised is faithful.
Sunday, June 28, 2009
Devilish lies
“There is a lot of debate about what the symbol of this Woman represents. Different.aspects of the symbol point to different possible meanings for it. Unfortunately, most of the debate over what the Woman represents is misdirected because it does not take into account the way that Revelation uses symbolism…The Woman in Revelation 12 is part of the fusion imagery/polyvalent symbolism that is found in the book. She has four referents: Israel, the Church, Eve, and Mary.”
http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1997/9705chap.asp
“Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.”
http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2009/06/tim-staples-says-its-wrong-to-clap-and.html?showComment=1246066958203#c346247913078320403
Symbolism? As in…metaphors (e.g. sun, moon, stars)?
But John never said these are metaphors. To treat this passage as a figurative description of Mary is clearly a lie from the devil. Or, at the very least, a lie from Jimmy Akin.
Catholic allegorical exegesis is a lie. A lie from the pit of hell. If you don't believe me, just ask Matthew Bellisario.
http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1997/9705chap.asp
“Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.”
http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2009/06/tim-staples-says-its-wrong-to-clap-and.html?showComment=1246066958203#c346247913078320403
Symbolism? As in…metaphors (e.g. sun, moon, stars)?
But John never said these are metaphors. To treat this passage as a figurative description of Mary is clearly a lie from the devil. Or, at the very least, a lie from Jimmy Akin.
Catholic allegorical exegesis is a lie. A lie from the pit of hell. If you don't believe me, just ask Matthew Bellisario.
Labels:
Catholicism,
Hays,
hermeneutics
Raiders of the Lost Marian Ark
“Spanning back to the authors of the early Church we can find a special veneration and love for the Mother of God, the Blessed Virgin Mary. More than just a mother, she was to be the vessel, or the Ark (Chrysippus (399-479) said, ‘The truly royal Ark, the most precious Ark, was the ever-Virgin Theotokos......’ In S. Mariam Deip in PO 19,338) which would house Our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.”
http://catholicchampion.blogspot.com/2008/11/most-holy-theotokos.html
“Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.”
http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2009/06/tim-staples-says-its-wrong-to-clap-and.html?showComment=1246066958203#c346247913078320403
Question: where does Moses say the ark was a metaphor for Mary?
http://catholicchampion.blogspot.com/2008/11/most-holy-theotokos.html
“Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.”
http://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2009/06/tim-staples-says-its-wrong-to-clap-and.html?showComment=1246066958203#c346247913078320403
Question: where does Moses say the ark was a metaphor for Mary?
Labels:
Catholicism,
Hays,
hermeneutics
Saturday, June 27, 2009
Upon this rock
[Beggars All] "The doctrine which maintains the change...transubstantiation.. is repugnant, not to Scripture alone, but even to common sense and reason...overthroweth..cause manifold superstitions..gross idolatries."
[Bellisario] "What is repugnant is that you reject Our Lord's words which tell us otherwise. Not you or your false confession [i.e. WCF] will ever change His words. Common sense does not give us the Gospel. Our lord did. You and your 'confession' reject Our lord and His words. Common sense tells me to listen to his words."
[TF] "Our Lord isn't the one who invented this concept of transubstantiation. He used a metaphor, but that's too common sense for some folks."
[Bellisario] "Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor."
http://turretinfan.blogspot.com/2009/06/transubstantiation-metaphor-and-common.html
Traditionally, Catholics invoke Mt 16:18 as their major prooftext for the papacy. According to the Catholic interpretation, when Jesus says he will build his church “on this rock,” the rock is a figurative allusion to the person of Peter (and, by extension, his successors).
Now, however, Matthew Bellisario has opened my eyes to the utterly repugnant nature of that inference.
It’s incumbent on the papist to prove that Jesus used a metaphor. To say “this rock” is a metaphor for St. Peter is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.
To the contrary, when Jesus says he will build his church “on this rock,” he means a real rock. An actual, literal rock.
The only remaining question is which rock represents the true rock? Which rock is the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic rock? Is it igneous, sedimentary, or metamorphic rock?
[Bellisario] "What is repugnant is that you reject Our Lord's words which tell us otherwise. Not you or your false confession [i.e. WCF] will ever change His words. Common sense does not give us the Gospel. Our lord did. You and your 'confession' reject Our lord and His words. Common sense tells me to listen to his words."
[TF] "Our Lord isn't the one who invented this concept of transubstantiation. He used a metaphor, but that's too common sense for some folks."
[Bellisario] "Prove He used a metaphor. That is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor."
http://turretinfan.blogspot.com/2009/06/transubstantiation-metaphor-and-common.html
Traditionally, Catholics invoke Mt 16:18 as their major prooftext for the papacy. According to the Catholic interpretation, when Jesus says he will build his church “on this rock,” the rock is a figurative allusion to the person of Peter (and, by extension, his successors).
Now, however, Matthew Bellisario has opened my eyes to the utterly repugnant nature of that inference.
It’s incumbent on the papist to prove that Jesus used a metaphor. To say “this rock” is a metaphor for St. Peter is a lie from the devil. Our Lord never said it was a metaphor.
To the contrary, when Jesus says he will build his church “on this rock,” he means a real rock. An actual, literal rock.
The only remaining question is which rock represents the true rock? Which rock is the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic rock? Is it igneous, sedimentary, or metamorphic rock?
Labels:
Catholicism,
Hays,
hermeneutics
Friday, June 26, 2009
The king of pop
Michael Jackson was one of those pop cultural phenomena I try my best to avoid. Of course, if you watch what passes for TV “news,” or even wait in the checkout stand, you can’t avoid some exposure. So I have a scattershot knowledge of Jackson, just like I have a scattershot knowledge of some other celebrities.
I’ve also glanced at a few Christian blogs on his death. What is there to say?
One thing that strikes me as how overrated he was. I keep running across the phrase “musical genius.” All I can say is that I don’t define musical genius the way some folks do.
What was it that made Jackson a bigger star than Ray Charles or Tina Turner or James Brown or Al Green or Johnny Cash or Ricky Martin or Henry Belafonte?
Does he have more talent? Charisma? Stage presence? Not that I can see.
At his peak he was a very energetic performer, but that’s a truism of youth. Aren’t we all energetic in our teens and twenties? And there are lots of hyperkinetic performers to choose from.
I guess that in his prime he was a good dancer, but you could say the same thing about a number of other entertainers.
I read about what a great singer he was. Oh, please!
To begin with, if you need a microphone, then you’re really not solo material.
But even by the inferior standards of pop vocalism, I can think of far more talented singers. Take Marion Williams.
So what makes him stand out in the pantheon pop culture? I think it has more to do with a calculated effort to redefine human nature. Transhumanism. Jackson was transhuman. He denied his race. Denied his gender.
Tina Turner isn’t my type, but one thing you can say about her–she’s all woman. There’s nothing ambiguous about her sexual or racial identity.
By the same token, entertainers like Johnny Cash and James Brown exude masculinity.
Entertainers like that are threatening to an ideology which is hell-bent on the subversion, inversion, and perversion what it means to be human. What it means to be male and female.
Take operas and musicals. Although these are often rather decadent, they are also quite heteronormative. Boy-meets-girl set to music.
By contrast, Jackson came to look and sound like a drag-queen. That makes him the poster child of transhumanism. Everything about him was fake. Ersatz. Ambiguous. And he had a lifestyle to match.
It’s a frontal assault on any residual Christian values. The futuristic face of secular humanism.
I’ve also glanced at a few Christian blogs on his death. What is there to say?
One thing that strikes me as how overrated he was. I keep running across the phrase “musical genius.” All I can say is that I don’t define musical genius the way some folks do.
What was it that made Jackson a bigger star than Ray Charles or Tina Turner or James Brown or Al Green or Johnny Cash or Ricky Martin or Henry Belafonte?
Does he have more talent? Charisma? Stage presence? Not that I can see.
At his peak he was a very energetic performer, but that’s a truism of youth. Aren’t we all energetic in our teens and twenties? And there are lots of hyperkinetic performers to choose from.
I guess that in his prime he was a good dancer, but you could say the same thing about a number of other entertainers.
I read about what a great singer he was. Oh, please!
To begin with, if you need a microphone, then you’re really not solo material.
But even by the inferior standards of pop vocalism, I can think of far more talented singers. Take Marion Williams.
So what makes him stand out in the pantheon pop culture? I think it has more to do with a calculated effort to redefine human nature. Transhumanism. Jackson was transhuman. He denied his race. Denied his gender.
Tina Turner isn’t my type, but one thing you can say about her–she’s all woman. There’s nothing ambiguous about her sexual or racial identity.
By the same token, entertainers like Johnny Cash and James Brown exude masculinity.
Entertainers like that are threatening to an ideology which is hell-bent on the subversion, inversion, and perversion what it means to be human. What it means to be male and female.
Take operas and musicals. Although these are often rather decadent, they are also quite heteronormative. Boy-meets-girl set to music.
By contrast, Jackson came to look and sound like a drag-queen. That makes him the poster child of transhumanism. Everything about him was fake. Ersatz. Ambiguous. And he had a lifestyle to match.
It’s a frontal assault on any residual Christian values. The futuristic face of secular humanism.
Thursday, June 25, 2009
Top news headlines!
(CNN) -- Entertainer Michael Jackson has died after being taken to a hospital on Thursday after suffering cardiac arrest, according to multiple reports including the Los Angeles Times and the Associated Press.
In other news of the day, The Jerusalem Post is reporting that Jesus Christ returned to earth today, accompanied by legions of angels.
And now back to our lead story: entertainer Michael Jackson has died after being taken to a hospital on Thursday.
In other news of the day, The Jerusalem Post is reporting that Jesus Christ returned to earth today, accompanied by legions of angels.
And now back to our lead story: entertainer Michael Jackson has died after being taken to a hospital on Thursday.
BREAKING NEWS! BREAKING NEWS! BREAKING NEWS!
(CNN) -- Entertainer Michael Jackson has died after being taken to a hospital on Thursday after suffering cardiac arrest, according to multiple reports including the Los Angeles Times and the Associated Press. CNN will bring you live, nonstop coverage of this developing story.
Due to a giant asteroid, which is scheduled to strike the earth at 10:53 PM EST, thereby extinguishing all forms of life on the surface of the earth, there may be a temporary interruption in our nonstop coverage of the Michael Jackson story. However, CNN has made arrangements with White House Press Secretary to continue broadcasting from the Cheyenne Mountain Operations Center to provide live, up-to-the-minute coverage of the Michael Jackson story. Stay tuned!
Due to a giant asteroid, which is scheduled to strike the earth at 10:53 PM EST, thereby extinguishing all forms of life on the surface of the earth, there may be a temporary interruption in our nonstop coverage of the Michael Jackson story. However, CNN has made arrangements with White House Press Secretary to continue broadcasting from the Cheyenne Mountain Operations Center to provide live, up-to-the-minute coverage of the Michael Jackson story. Stay tuned!
Time Management, Cinema, And The Danger Of Triviality
John Piper:
I think relevance in preaching hangs very little on watching movies, and I think that much exposure to sensuality, banality, and God-absent entertainment does more to deaden our capacities for joy in Jesus than it does to make us spiritually powerful in the lives of the living dead. Sources of spiritual power—which are what we desperately need—are not in the cinema. You will not want your biographer to write: Prick him and he bleeds movies.
If you want to be relevant, say, for prostitutes, don’t watch a movie with a lot of tumbles in a brothel. Immerse yourself in the gospel, which is tailor-made for prostitutes; then watch Jesus deal with them in the Bible; then go find a prostitute and talk to her. Listen to her, not the movie. Being entertained by sin does not increase compassion for sinners.
There are, perhaps, a few extraordinary men who can watch action-packed, suspenseful, sexually explicit films and come away more godly. But there are not many. And I am certainly not one of them.
I have a high tolerance for violence, high tolerance for bad language, and zero tolerance for nudity. There is a reason for these differences. The violence is make-believe. They don’t really mean those bad words. But that lady is really naked, and I am really watching. And somewhere she has a brokenhearted father.
I’ll put it bluntly. The only nude female body a guy should ever lay his eyes on is his wife’s. The few exceptions include doctors, morticians, and fathers changing diapers....
But leave sex aside (as if that were possible for fifteen minutes on TV). It’s the unremitting triviality that makes television so deadly. What we desperately need is help to enlarge our capacities to be moved by the immeasurable glories of Christ. Television takes us almost constantly in the opposite direction, lowering, shrinking, and deadening our capacities for worshiping Christ.
One more smaller concern with TV (besides its addictive tendencies, trivialization of life, and deadening effects): It takes time. I have so many things I want to accomplish in this one short life. Don’t waste your life is not a catchphrase for me; it’s a cliff I walk beside every day with trembling.
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
The Bible of the Apostles
If we agree with the ancient Jews that the LXX translation was a faulty translation, then why is such a substandard text part of Holy, Inspired Scripture? Doesn't the New Testament suggest that the LXX was considered not just trustworthy, but even preferred by the Apostles? This is not out of harmony with the testimony of the Early Church, which regarded it as a sound and inspired translation.
As a Bible believing Christian, facing this dilemma was not easy. I felt that by trying to honestly grapple with textual issues, I was questioning the authority of God's Word. This is not at all what I intended. I simply wanted integrity in my Christian faith. With time, as I struggled through some of these facts, I realized I needed to come to Scripture on its own terms, not on my expectations as a twentieth century Westerner. This desire for integrity aided me as I swallowed hard and proceeded to study the canon of the Old Testament.
The Eastern Orthodox Church has been most faithful to the apostles' Old Testament. They still use the LXX and usually base their translations of the Old Testament on it. Without needing objective proof for the veracity of this translation, they have simply held to what the apostles gave them. Their approach to the canon has not been philosophical or deductive, but spiritual, trusting that God established and is now watching over the Church He established.
http://www.kalvesmaki.com/otcanon.htm
There are some serious problems with this argument:
1. Needless to say, our extant editions of the LXX are not identical with the 1C editions of the Greek OT which NT authors had at their disposal. Therefore, it’s anachronistic as well as inaccurate to simply correlate one with the other.
2. As NT scholars have pointed out, NT writers don't simply quote the Greek OT verbatim. Rather, they feel free to reword their source. In that event, they don’t treat the wording of the Greek OT as inviolate.
3.To say NT writers quote the Greek OT doesn’t mean they quote the Greek OT exclusively. Some of their quotations are closer to the MT.
4.We also need to distinguish between NT speakers and NT writers. When NT writers quote NT speakers quoting the OT, they tend to use the Greek OT. But they also do so in settings where it’s unlikely that the speaker himself was quoting from the Greek OT. That would only make sense if they were addressing a Greek-speaking audience.
So this is probably a case in which the writer substitutes a different version for the benefit of the reader, in distinction to the original speaker and his immediate audience.
5. Apropos (4), NT writers quote the Greek OT because they’re writing to Greek-speaking Jews and Gentiles. For example the author of Hebrews is addressing Hellenistic Jewish-Christians. Therefore, as a practical necessity, he’s going to use a Greek version of the OT. That’s an unavoidable accommodation to his audience. An exercise in audience-adaptation.
Indeed, his use of the Greek OT may well be ad hominem. Answering them on their own terms by appealing to their own methods and sources.
As a Bible believing Christian, facing this dilemma was not easy. I felt that by trying to honestly grapple with textual issues, I was questioning the authority of God's Word. This is not at all what I intended. I simply wanted integrity in my Christian faith. With time, as I struggled through some of these facts, I realized I needed to come to Scripture on its own terms, not on my expectations as a twentieth century Westerner. This desire for integrity aided me as I swallowed hard and proceeded to study the canon of the Old Testament.
The Eastern Orthodox Church has been most faithful to the apostles' Old Testament. They still use the LXX and usually base their translations of the Old Testament on it. Without needing objective proof for the veracity of this translation, they have simply held to what the apostles gave them. Their approach to the canon has not been philosophical or deductive, but spiritual, trusting that God established and is now watching over the Church He established.
http://www.kalvesmaki.com/otcanon.htm
There are some serious problems with this argument:
1. Needless to say, our extant editions of the LXX are not identical with the 1C editions of the Greek OT which NT authors had at their disposal. Therefore, it’s anachronistic as well as inaccurate to simply correlate one with the other.
2. As NT scholars have pointed out, NT writers don't simply quote the Greek OT verbatim. Rather, they feel free to reword their source. In that event, they don’t treat the wording of the Greek OT as inviolate.
3.To say NT writers quote the Greek OT doesn’t mean they quote the Greek OT exclusively. Some of their quotations are closer to the MT.
4.We also need to distinguish between NT speakers and NT writers. When NT writers quote NT speakers quoting the OT, they tend to use the Greek OT. But they also do so in settings where it’s unlikely that the speaker himself was quoting from the Greek OT. That would only make sense if they were addressing a Greek-speaking audience.
So this is probably a case in which the writer substitutes a different version for the benefit of the reader, in distinction to the original speaker and his immediate audience.
5. Apropos (4), NT writers quote the Greek OT because they’re writing to Greek-speaking Jews and Gentiles. For example the author of Hebrews is addressing Hellenistic Jewish-Christians. Therefore, as a practical necessity, he’s going to use a Greek version of the OT. That’s an unavoidable accommodation to his audience. An exercise in audience-adaptation.
Indeed, his use of the Greek OT may well be ad hominem. Answering them on their own terms by appealing to their own methods and sources.
Labels:
canonics,
Hays,
hermeneutics,
Orthodoxy
Classical Arminianism less loving than other varients on Arminianism, or does it lead to means-end irrationality, Universalism or Open Theism?
Jason Pratt said: "But being love, God will keep persisting--including in chastisement and discipline, toward accomplishing re-tribution, re-mediation, re-probation in and with the sinner.”
I take it that this expresses a popular Arminian understanding of God's attitude toward those in hell.
Now add to this classical omniscience, and you either have a means-end irrational God or Universalism or Open Theism. I'm trying to figure out how this isn't so...
(Of course, the Classical Arminian can resort to a retributive view of hell I guess, but then he needs to answer the Universalist's question: How is this God omni-loving? In other words, the Classical Arminian gets hoisted by his own petard here.)
I take it that this expresses a popular Arminian understanding of God's attitude toward those in hell.
Now add to this classical omniscience, and you either have a means-end irrational God or Universalism or Open Theism. I'm trying to figure out how this isn't so...
(Of course, the Classical Arminian can resort to a retributive view of hell I guess, but then he needs to answer the Universalist's question: How is this God omni-loving? In other words, the Classical Arminian gets hoisted by his own petard here.)
Labels:
Arminianism,
Foreknowledge,
Hell,
Open Theism,
Universalism
Mother Church or mother of schism?
The Catholic church prides itself on being a beacon of unity in a sea of chaos. It decries the proliferation of religious “sects.” It lays exclusive claim to Jn 17:21-22. It promotes ecumenism, in the one-sided sense of calling on all Christian denominations to return to Mother church.
What’s ironic and indeed hypocritical about all this is that the Catholic church is a very divisive force in Christendom. The Catholic church is a precipitating factor in many “schisms.”
We could run down a very long list. I’ll just cite a few examples to illustrate the point.
Quartodecimanism
Pope Victor unilaterally excommunicated Christians living in the East who celebrated Easter on a different date than Rome. That’s hardly an action that promotes church unity. And it was a completely unnecessary controversy.
The Filioque
At some point the Filioque clause was added to the Nicene Creed, and the church of Rome formalized that addition. I’m not debating the merits of the Filioque. I’m merely pointing out that the actions of Rome were very divisive in that respect.
Tridentine Canon
At the Council of Trent, the Tridentine Fathers were divided over the scope of the OT canon, for tradition itself was divided over the scope of the OT canon. Yet Trent decided to anathematize Christians who rejected the Apocrypha. That was a very exclusionary action.
Assumption of Mary
In 1950, Piux XII elevated the Assumption of Mary to Catholic dogma. This was despite the fact that this dogma lacked any solid foundation in the traditions of the ancient church. Anyone dissident was implicitly forced to leave the church.
Novus Ordo
When, in the wake of Vatican II, the papacy introduced a revised Missal, this was a very disruptive action, and predictably so.
For one thing, Catholic apologists used to invoke the Latin Mass as an emblem of Catholic unity and universality. A Catholic who traveled to any part of the world where the Mass was celebrated would hear the Mass in the same language (Latin). By using the vernacular, this destroyed the unity and universality of worship. (Not to mention additional changes to the Missal.)
Anglican Orders
In 1896, Leo XIII nullified Anglican ordinations. By definition, that was a very exclusionary action.
When the Catholic church takes these actions, there are winners and losers. The winners draw lines which create insiders and outsiders. It generates de facto and de jure schisms.
Now, I’m not saying that’s good or bad. And I don’t have a personal stake in some of these controversies.
My point is simply that the Catholic church has frequently taken provocative actions which disenfranchise many professing believers. The Catholic church has deliberately instigated many schisms through its factious and fractious policies. It uses its unilateral ax to split Christendom into many different splinter groups.
Now, if you’re Catholic, you can claim that all these actions were justified. I’m not debating the merits of each case. I’m simply noting a fundamental tension between the claims of Rome to be a champion of Christian unity, as well as a leader in ecumenical dialogue–on the one hand–and various actions by which she has alienated many professing believers and ejected them from the ranks of the “faithful”–retroactively defined.
What’s ironic and indeed hypocritical about all this is that the Catholic church is a very divisive force in Christendom. The Catholic church is a precipitating factor in many “schisms.”
We could run down a very long list. I’ll just cite a few examples to illustrate the point.
Quartodecimanism
Pope Victor unilaterally excommunicated Christians living in the East who celebrated Easter on a different date than Rome. That’s hardly an action that promotes church unity. And it was a completely unnecessary controversy.
The Filioque
At some point the Filioque clause was added to the Nicene Creed, and the church of Rome formalized that addition. I’m not debating the merits of the Filioque. I’m merely pointing out that the actions of Rome were very divisive in that respect.
Tridentine Canon
At the Council of Trent, the Tridentine Fathers were divided over the scope of the OT canon, for tradition itself was divided over the scope of the OT canon. Yet Trent decided to anathematize Christians who rejected the Apocrypha. That was a very exclusionary action.
Assumption of Mary
In 1950, Piux XII elevated the Assumption of Mary to Catholic dogma. This was despite the fact that this dogma lacked any solid foundation in the traditions of the ancient church. Anyone dissident was implicitly forced to leave the church.
Novus Ordo
When, in the wake of Vatican II, the papacy introduced a revised Missal, this was a very disruptive action, and predictably so.
For one thing, Catholic apologists used to invoke the Latin Mass as an emblem of Catholic unity and universality. A Catholic who traveled to any part of the world where the Mass was celebrated would hear the Mass in the same language (Latin). By using the vernacular, this destroyed the unity and universality of worship. (Not to mention additional changes to the Missal.)
Anglican Orders
In 1896, Leo XIII nullified Anglican ordinations. By definition, that was a very exclusionary action.
When the Catholic church takes these actions, there are winners and losers. The winners draw lines which create insiders and outsiders. It generates de facto and de jure schisms.
Now, I’m not saying that’s good or bad. And I don’t have a personal stake in some of these controversies.
My point is simply that the Catholic church has frequently taken provocative actions which disenfranchise many professing believers. The Catholic church has deliberately instigated many schisms through its factious and fractious policies. It uses its unilateral ax to split Christendom into many different splinter groups.
Now, if you’re Catholic, you can claim that all these actions were justified. I’m not debating the merits of each case. I’m simply noting a fundamental tension between the claims of Rome to be a champion of Christian unity, as well as a leader in ecumenical dialogue–on the one hand–and various actions by which she has alienated many professing believers and ejected them from the ranks of the “faithful”–retroactively defined.
Labels:
Catholicism,
ecumenism,
Hays,
Unity
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)