Showing posts with label Fortunatianus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fortunatianus. Show all posts

Sunday, July 07, 2024

Some Church Fathers On The Efficaciousness Of Prebaptismal Faith

Some of the church fathers who use highly efficacious language about baptism also use highly efficacious language, including language about the new birth and salvation, when discussing prebaptismal faith. However you explain that (that they viewed justification as a multistep process, that they were inconsistent, or whatever), it offers partial corroboration for the view that we're justified through prebaptismal faith. They ascribe more to prebaptismal faith than advocates of baptismal regeneration typically do. It also provides another example of the diversity of the baptismal beliefs of the pre-Reformation sources. The historian Nick Needham writes that the view of these fathers "effectively makes initial justification itself a twofold process: faith introduces us to salvation, and baptism perfects the introduction" (in Bruce McCormack, ed., Justification In Perspective [Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic, 2006], 42). He cites Origen, Cyril of Jerusalem, and Basil of Caesarea as examples. He goes on, "Basil's use of 'seal' imagery may indicate that he regarded baptism as the public and official declaration of a justification that until then has been private and unofficial" (ibid.). Whether you explain these fathers' comments as Needham does, explain them in some other way, or remain agnostic about it, I agree that such comments are found in the three fathers he mentions. At least in the passages I've read, it's clearer in Cyril and Basil than in Origen, but seems likely to be present in Origen as well. It may also be present in a Western source of the fourth century, Fortunatianus, though his comments are highly metaphorical and harder to interpret. He wrote in his Commentary On The Gospels:

Sunday, August 27, 2017

Fortunatianus' Commentary On The Gospels

There have been some media stories lately about the recent discovery and English translation of a fourth-century patristic work that was previously lost. For the background, see my Facebook post here. Having read the English translation, I want to expand upon that post. All numbers that follow in parentheses will be references to page numbers in the English translation just linked.

The media and the document's English translator, Hugh Houghton, have given a lot of attention to the highly allegorical nature of Fortunatianus' interpretation of the gospels. The allegorical approach supplemented a grammatical/historical one rather than replacing it. See, for example, Fortunatianus' comments affirming the historicity of the magi giving gifts to Jesus (18), the miracles Jesus performed (65), the miraculous events around the time of Jesus' death (95), etc. He harmonizes Jesus' genealogies (6-7). He refers to how Matthew, as an evangelist, "is not permitted to lie or deceive" (10). He tells us that John received "careful guidance" from the Holy Spirit when writing and "knew all secrets" (100-101). Fortunatianus sometimes tells us that an alleged allegory in scripture is referring to something supernatural, like the virgin birth (80), or is referring to something else that critics of Christianity often reject, so how can such allegorizing be equated to a rejection of such beliefs? And so on. Ironically, some of the places where Fortunatianus is most explicit in affirming the historicity of the gospels are when writing about accounts whose historicity surely would be rejected by people in the media and elsewhere who are appealing to his allegorizing. But since he is so allegorical in his interpretation, another point ought to be made on that subject.

The allegorizing discredits itself. It sinks from its own dead weight. If you want to see how superior grammatical/historical interpretation is and the unverifiable and dangerous nature of allegorical interpretation, read a work like Fortunatianus' commentary. Here are a few examples: