Showing posts with label Andrew Lincoln. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrew Lincoln. Show all posts

Thursday, August 04, 2016

Improvising morality

A few years ago, NT scholar Andrew Lincoln published a book attacking the Virgin Birth. Jason did a multipart critical review:


And I did some posting:



Now, however, I'd like to draw attention to something else. Does Lincoln have an ulterior motive for undermining the historicity of the Virgin Birth? Last year he contributed to a book in which he makes some revealing statements about his theological motivations:

My views about the truth of the Bible and its relation to faith continue to evolve in response to…factors, such as…church life and its mission of social justice, friendships. Times of radical questioning have been precipitated not by academic study of the Bible but more by crises in my personal life and relationships, by my and the church's failure to be loving… 
So there was immediately a much greater recognition that the Bible's authority was not to be thought of as timeless in some unqualified sense. That deepening recognition was already preparing me to think about questions that confronted me in the first two setting in which I taught–about women's ordained ministry at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and about homosexuality at St. John's College, Nottingham. Although I started off by thinking that traditionalists had the better exegetical case on these matters and that should be decisive, my pastoral experience with women students, who were highly gifted in teaching and preaching, and with gay ordinands, who had prayed and agonized about their sexuality for years and were placed in the invidious position of hoping their future bishops would be those who deliberately turned a blind eye to official teaching, caused me to rethink what the Bible's authority meant in such cases…This involves, as some put it, "improvising"… I (Still) Believe: Leading Bible Scholars Share Their Stories of Faith and Scholarship (Zondervan 2015), 148-149.

So Lincoln has a social agenda. He doesn't begin with principles, but people. He adapts and changes his view of Biblical authority based on personal experience and personal relationships. 

Given his frank admission, you can see how attacking the historicity of the Virgin Birth (or the historicity of John's Gospel) drives another wedge into the authority of Scripture, thereby making room for his "social justice" concerns. 

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Responding To Andrew Lincoln On The Virgin Birth

Last year, a New Testament scholar, Andrew Lincoln, published a book arguing against the virgin birth. Some New Testament scholars have responded to him since then, but every one of their responses to Lincoln's book that I've seen so far hasn't gone into much depth. For anybody who's interested in a lengthy review that argues for the historicity of the virgin birth, here's a response to Lincoln's book that I wrote last year.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Attacking the Virgin Birth


I'm going to quote, then comment on, some arguments by Andrew Lincoln:

It should be apparent, then, that in this area Matthew's and Luke's birth stories also provide the features that would be expected of an ancient biography's depiction of the beginnings of the life of a great figure. In Matthew there are Joseph's dreams, the angel's prediction of the child's future role as Saviour, the fulfillment of earlier predictions from the Scriptures, the magi who are the equivalent of the diviners, the portent of the star, and the accompanying attempt to prevent the birth of male children. In Luke there are again angelic predictions of the future greatness of Mary's child, the omen of Elizabeth's baby leaping in her womb at the appearances of the pregnant Mary and the accompanying explanation, the glory of the Lord shining around the shepherds as the angelic announcement is made to them, and both Simeon and Anna immediately recognizing in Mary's child the one who is to bring salvation to Israel, with Simeon also predicting his destiny.
There are further correspondences with Graeco-Roman biographies. Matthew began his story with a genealogy (cf. also Luke 3:23-38). As might be expected, other biographers also provide material on the family lineage of their subjects…Diogenes Laertius follows Plato's family back through Solon to Neptune…The naming of Jesus and the meaning of his names are particularly important in Matthew's narrative. A similar concern is found in Plutarch about the names of Romulus and Remus and Theseus.
Sometimes such biographies recount something miraculous about the birth of the subject…Plutarch provides three examples. In relating the origins of Romulus…The two boys, Romulus and Remus, are taken away and looked after by a wolf and a woodpecker…Like Romulus, Theseus "got the reputation of descent from gods…that he was begotten by Poseidon."
In Plutarch's biography of Alexander, Philip sees Apollo, under the form of a serpent, lying with his wife…Suetonius has a similar story about Augustus' conception. His mother, Atia, falls asleep in the temple of Apollo. Apollo comes to her in the form of a snake…Porphyry recounts that Pythagoras was said to be the son of Apollo.
In relation to Tiberius, Suetonius relates how an eagle landed on the roof of his house and underlines that he was confident of his destiny because of the predictions of astrologers…His account of Vespasian lists a number of portents of his future imperial dignity, including a prediction from Josephus and incidents involving a dog, an ox and eagles.
Philostratus relates that Apollonius' mother had an apparition of Proteus, the Egyptian god, in the guise of a demon before the birth of her son...
These examples indicate that major elements in the infancy narratives of Matthew and Luke bear a remarkable resemblance to what is to be found in Graeco-Roman biographies at the places where they treat the early stages of their subjects' lives before their public arena…In this material ancestry, names, and geographical and political setting may well have support from tradition, but much of the content, whether traditional or not, involves notions about the gods, fate, auguries, portents, divination and astrology that are legendary but nevertheless illustrate the significance that became attached to the subject's life. Born of a Virgin? (Eerdmans 2013), 60,62-63,65-66.

i) One preliminary observation: Lincoln defends the mutual independence of the Matthean and Lucan nativity accounts (129ff). That, however, would mean we have multiple-attestation for the virgin birth. 

ii) It's striking that a NT scholar of Lincoln's distinction would resort to such atrocious comparative methodology. I guess the best explanation is that because he finds the virgin birth incredible, he's forced to justify his infidelity at whatever cost. Lincoln's handling of sources is naive and sloppy. He fails to draw elementary distinctions or make allowance for obvious considerations:

iii) The need to distinguish between historical figures and mythological figures. In the nature of the case, legendary embellishment can only apply to someone who actually existed, not to fictional demigods like Romulus, Remus, and Theseus. In the case of mythological figures, the entire "biography" is invented whole cloth. There are no factual constraints on what can be said about them.

iv) The difference between writing about a contemporary or near contemporary, in contrast to a public figure who lived and died generations before the historian or biographer. In the case of figures who died within living memory, reliable information is still available. 

v) We must also take into account the motivations of court historians and royal biographers who make their living by churning out flattering propaganda about their Roman overlords, or ex post facto legitimation of the Roman regime by concocting or elaborating a chauvinistic national mythology. Josephus, Plutarch, and Suetonius are all pandering to their social superiors, to ingratiate themselves with the powers that be. It's a classic client/patron relationship. 

vi) Perhaps Lincoln imagines that Luke's relationship to Theophilus is comparable. However, if Luke was so motivated, he'd do for Caesar what he does instead for Jesus and John the Baptist.    

vii) All of the examples he gives in Matthew and Luke have OT precedents. So it's anachronistic for Lincoln to attribute that to Greco-Roman biographical conventions.

viii) Even on their own terms, why does Lincoln assume that Greco-Roman biographers and historians simply invented stories about prophetic dreams and celestial portents? The ancients really did believe dreams could be prophetic. 

Lincoln fails to distinguish between inventing a prophetic dream, and recounting a real dream to which you ascribe prophetic significance. Oneiromancy isn't about inventing dreams, but interpreting dreams. A dream can be quite real without it being really prophetic. 

Likewise, why does Lincoln assume that Greco-Roman biographers and historians simply invented stories about stellar prodigies? Ancient people really did believe certain astronomical phenomena portended the future. Lincoln fails to distinguish between inventing an astronomical sign, and ascribing prophetic significance to an actual astronomical phenomenon. 

Astrologers don't need to invent comets, meteors, eclipses, conjunctions, &c. Astrologers are inventive, but not in that respect. Rather, they offer ingenious interpretations of birthdates in relation to the position of the stars, &c.  

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

More About Andrew Lincoln's Book On The Virgin Birth

Larry Hurtado has posted some comments on Andrew Lincoln's book about the virgin birth. For those who don't know, I responded to Lincoln's book in a series of articles last week. Here are a couple of significant posts from the comments section of Hurtado's thread:

My [Larry Hurtado's] review will appears sometime in the Spring 2014 in Expository Times, but I was assigned a limited number of words. So, it won’t be a really adequate engagement on critical issues. That’s something that the book certainly requires and deserves.

And Richard Bauckham commented:

One point at which Lincoln is wrong is that he claims biographers themselves made up stories about portents and remarkable events connected with the births of important people. (Miraculous births and conceptions as such are very rare, prophecies and portents more common.) What the biographers (Plutarch, Suetonius and others) actually do is report stories that were already circulating. They say so. Sometimes they report them without committing themselves to their truth. Sometimes they have no such stories, presumably because there were none available to them. So I don’t think we should assume that such things were understood as just a literary convention or conclude too readily that Luke would have just composed his birth narratives de novo.

Friday, November 08, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 6)

(Go to the following links for previous parts in the series: part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4, part 5.)


Lincoln often compares the gospels to ancient accounts of pagan gods, emperors, and other figures whose lives are commonly thought to have been recorded unreliably (in part or in whole). The frequent paralleling of the gospels with such accounts is accompanied by a lack of discussion of the most significant evidence that distinguishes the gospels from those other sources. Lincoln sometimes makes comments such as:

Thursday, November 07, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 5)

(Go to the following links for previous parts in the series: part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4.)


If the belief that Joseph was the natural father of Jesus was the majority position among Christians during the first several decades of church history, non-Christians should easily have recognized that fact and would have had reason to make much of it. The change Lincoln proposes, in which there was a shift from claiming natural descent from Joseph to claiming a virgin birth, supposedly occurred shortly before or during the lifetime of the most prominent critics of Christianity in the second century. Does the information we have about the early opponents of Christianity suggest that such a shift occurred?

Wednesday, November 06, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 4)

(Go to the following links for previous parts in the series: part 1, part 2, part 3.)


Consider the implications of Lincoln's reading of the New Testament. He thinks belief in Joseph as the natural father of Jesus was the majority position among the Christians of the New Testament era. He thinks the view is found in documents he assigns to the end of the first century (186), perhaps even later in one or more cases. He claims that the view was held by such influential figures as Paul and the authors of Mark's gospel and the Johannine literature. Think of all of the individuals, churches, and other groups influenced by such leaders, including through their writings. Accordingly, we'd expect the view that Jesus was conceived through sexual intercourse between Joseph and Mary to be widespread in the early extrabiblical Christian and non-Christian sources. Is that what we find? I'll address the early Christian sources in this post and the early non-Christian sources in the post that follows.

Tuesday, November 05, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 3)

(Go to the following links for previous parts in the series: part 1, part 2.)


I agree with much of what Lincoln says about the virgin birth in Matthew. The concept is found in Matthew's gospel, but not as clearly as most people think. I would argue, however, that the evidence for a virgin birth in Matthew is somewhat better than Lincoln suggests.

Monday, November 04, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 2)

(To read part 1, go here.)


There's a lesson to be learned from the title of Lincoln's book. What do people have in mind when they refer to Jesus' being "born of a virgin"? They may be thinking of a virginal conception, without the intention of suggesting that Mary remained a virgin until after the birth. The point is that the child was born from a woman who was a virgin at the time of conception. Others accept the historicity of Matthew 1:25 as a reference to Mary's virginity until after the birth, so they think she was a virgin both at the time of conception and at the time when Jesus was born. Some would include virginity in partu, while others would define the virginity as consisting only of the avoidance of sexual intercourse. Terms like "born of a virgin" and "virgin birth" are somewhat flexible.

Sunday, November 03, 2013

Andrew Lincoln's Book Against The Virgin Birth (Part 1)

(This will be a six-part series. All six parts will be linked in one post after the series has been completed.)


Andrew Lincoln, a New Testament scholar, recently published Born Of A Virgin? (London, England: SPCK, 2013). I've read the British edition. The American version is due out next month. Lincoln is a supernaturalist who accepts traditional Christian concepts like the deity of Jesus and his resurrection, but rejects other traditional positions, such as Biblical inerrancy and the historicity of the virgin birth. He thinks Joseph was Jesus' natural father.

On the back cover, James McGrath of Butler University calls Lincoln's book "groundbreaking…excellent…sure to be considered the volume to turn to on this topic for many years to come." Edward Adams of King's College London refers to it as "thorough…the most important contribution to the subject of Jesus' earthly origins for many years." Helen Bond of the University of Edinburgh calls it "masterly" and comments that "I cannot recommend it highly enough." Robert Morgan of Linacre College, Oxford refers to "Lincoln's masterly literary and historical analyses…theological and hermeneutical reflection at its best".